Overall feedback indicates the toner is well-liked for combination to oily skin due to its fresh, non-drying feel and pore-tightening effect. Customers appreciate its gentle texture and compatibility with clarins cleansers. However, a recent formula and packaging change has divided opinions: some users report an unpleasant stronger scent, sticky residue, or stinging/allergic reactions. Packaging changes removed pumps on larger bottles, though delivery and refill availability remain positive.