Overall customers find this waterproof mascara reliable and well-suited for everyday use. Reviewers consistently praise its intense black pigment, good lash separation, lightweight feel, and waterproof longevity. It builds into a natural look and is appreciated for its hourglass-shaped wand and vegan/cruelty-free formulation. Common drawbacks include limited lengthening for some users, slow drying time, small tube size, and difficulty removing without oil. There are also occasional reports of transfer during application, mixed suitability for hooded eyes, and some perceptions of chunky packaging.